Research Article


DOI :10.26650/jes.2020.012   IUP :10.26650/jes.2020.012    Full Text (PDF)

Ahmed bey Agaoglu: Portrait Traits of Identity as a Lawyer

Mehman Damirli

In this article one of the unexplored areas, namely the law-related area of activity and creativity of Ahmed bey Agaoglu (1869-1939) is examined. Initially assessing the multi-dimensional activities of A. Agaoglu as a lawyer, four key areas of this activity are identified, and Agaoglu’s contributions to each of these areas are generally characterized. Then, the contribution of Agaoglu as a lawyer-pedagogue to the teaching of law in Turkey's two main universities is pointed out and his textbooks on constitutional law and legal history are covered. Further, based on the works of the thinker reflecting his public and political views, his legal views are analyzed and his opinions on a number of theoretical issues of law, such as understanding of law, individual freedoms, the relationship between rights and duties, and the relationship between law and religion, are examined. In the research, based on the analysis of various aspects of Agaoglu's activity related to law, the portrait of his identity as a lawyer is depicted in its following main traits: (1) as a fighter and consistent defender of the rights of Azerbaijani Turks and of all Turkish Muslims, as well as of women's rights, (2) as an influential deputy represented in the supreme legislative bodies of Ottoman and Republic Turkey and the Azerbaijan Democratik Republic, (3) as a lawyer-pedagogue and (4) as a liberal-minded lawyer-thinker.

DOI :10.26650/jes.2020.012   IUP :10.26650/jes.2020.012    Full Text (PDF)

Əhməd Bəy Ağaoğlu: Hüquqçu Kimliyinin Portret Cizgiləri

Mehman Damirli

Təqdim edilən məqalədə Əhməd bəy Ağaoğlunun (1869-1939) fəaliyyət və yaradıcılığının yetərincə tədqiq edilməmiş sahələrindən biri – huquqla bağlı sahəsi araşdırılır. Öncə hüquqçu olaraq Ə. Ağaoğlunun çoxyönlü fəaliyyəti ilkin dəyərləndirilməklə, bu fəaliyyətin dörd önəmli istiqaməti müəyyən edilir, eləcə də həmin istiqamətlərin hər biri üzrə Əhməd bəyin töhfələri ümumi olaraq səciyyələndirilir. Sonra hüquqçu pedaqoq kimi Ə. Ağaoğlunun Türkiyənin iki əsas ali məktəbində hüququn tədrisinə töhfəsi diqqət mərkəzinə gətirilməklə, onun konstitusiya hüququ və ümumi hüquq tarixi sahələrindəki dərs kitabları əsas cizgiləri ilə ələ alınır. Daha sonra mütəfəkkirin ictimai-siyasi baxışlarının əks olunduğu əsərləri əsasında onun hüquqi görüşləri ortaya qoyulur, hüquq anlayışı, fərdi azadlıqlar, hüquq və vəzifələrin əlaqəsi, hüquq və din münasibətləri kimi hüququn bir sıra təməl nəzəri məsələlərinə dair fikirləri incələnir. Araşdırmada Ə. Ağaoğlunun hüquqla bağlı fəaliyyətinin müxtəlif yönlərinin təhlili əsasında onun hüquqçu kimliyinin portreti əsas cizgilərilə canlandırılır. Belə ki, tədqiqat nəticəsində Əhməd bəy göz önündə həm (1) Azərbaycan türklərinin və bütün türk müsəlmanların hüquqlarının, eləcə də qadın hüquqlarının mübariz ve ardıcıl müdafiəçisi kimi, həm (2) Osmanlı və Cümhuriyyət Türkiyəsinin və Azərbaycan Xalq Cümhuriyyətinin ali qanunverici orqanlarında təmsil olunan nüfuzlu millət vəkili kimi, həm (3) hüquqçu pedaqoq kimi və həm də (4) liberal görüşlü hüquqçu düşüncə adamı kimi durur.


EXTENDED ABSTRACT


Recently, despite the growing interest in the socio-political, scientific, and literary activities of Ahmed Bey Agaoglu (1869-1939) and the emergence of a number of works based on a thorough study of various aspects of his rich creativity, unexplored aspects of the activity and creativity of the thinker still remain. One such unexplored aspect is the law-related activities and creativity of Ahmed Bey, who was a graduate of Sarbonna Law School. Currently there is a clear gap in this area. The purpose of the present research is to fill that gap as much as possible.

In the article, initially assessing the multi-dimensional activities of A. Agaoglu as a lawyer, four key areas of this activity are identified, and Agaoglu’s contributions to each of these areas are generally characterized. Then, the contribution of Agaoglu as a lawyer-pedagogue to the teaching of law in Turkey's two main universities is pointed out and his textbooks on constitutional law and legal history are covered. Further, based on the works of the thinker reflecting his public and political views, his legal views are analyzed and his opinions on a number of theoretical issues of law, such as understanding of law, individual freedoms, the relationship between rights and duties, and the relationship between law and religion, are examined.

In particular, it is noted that Agaoglu defined law as a dynamic social phenomenon which regulates relationships between individuals and thereby he stood in the position of a sociological approach to law. Agaoglu considered the existence of individual freedoms an important prerequisite for the development of societies and cultures, and highly valued their role. In his view, societies without individual freedoms cannot go ahead. One of the most important components of Agaoglu's understanding of law was the principle of respect for citizens' rights. According to him, societies without rights can not survive and thrive. In such societies, generally, "the concept of law disappears and society is thrown away like a lifeless, inactive toy." Furthermore, where people are ignorant of their rights, “justice is gone, and public life is ruined.” The realization of rights involves the execution of relevant duties as a necessary condition and guarantee. According to Agaoglu, since it is not possible to ensure rights without duty, "to think of duty without right also is to put all human beings in the place of animals." By attaching a broader social and moral meaning on the close relationship between rights and duties, the thinker considered the protection of rights the "highest and most honorable duty" of members of society.

In research based on the analysis of various aspects of Agaoglu's activity related to law, his portrait of identity as a lawyer is depicted in its following main traits: (1) as a fighter and consistent defender of the rights of Azerbaijani Turks and of all Turkish Muslims, as well as of women's rights, (2) as an influential deputy represented in the supreme legislative bodies of Ottoman and Republic Turkey and the Azerbaijan Democratic Republic, (3) as a lawyerpedagogue, who educated his students in the spirit of respect for the advanced political, legal and moral values of their time, whose textbooks on the subjects of constitutional law and history of law were the first in Turkey in this field, and (4) as a liberal-minded lawyer-thinker, who embraced a sociological understanding of law, advocated the secularization of law by separating it from religion, and considered the extension of individual freedoms an important factor in the development of society, and the protection of human rights and freedoms as the main objective of the democratic state's legal system.


PDF View

References

  • AĞAOĞLU, Ahmet, (1931-1932), Hukuk Tarihi, Ağaoğlu Ahmet beyin takrirleri (Talebe Nijat bey tarafından tutulmuş), 1931-1932 ders senesi, Hukuk Talebesi Cəmiyyəti Yayınları, İstanbul: Kurtuluş matbaası. google scholar
  • AĞAOĞLU, Ahmet, (1933), Devlet ve Fert, İstanbul: Sanayiinefise Matbaası. google scholar
  • AĞAOĞLU, Ahmet, (1938a), “Basitten Mürekkebe, Şekilsizlikten Şekilleşmeye Doğru”, İnsan, C. I, S. 3, 15 Haziran: s. 204-208. google scholar
  • AĞAOĞLU, Ahmet, (1938b), “Dinde Manizme İçtimai Hayatta da Sınıflara ve Büyük Malikanelere Doğru”, İnsan, C. I, S. 7, 15 Birincikanun: s. 356-360. google scholar
  • AĞAOĞLU, Ahmet, (1938c), “Hukukta Tekamül Devirleri”, İnsan, C. I, S. 2, 15 Mayıs: s. 117-123. google scholar
  • AĞAOĞLU, Ahmet, (1938ç), “İştirakçilikten Ferdi Mesaiye ve Mülkiyete Doğru”, İnsan, C. I, S. 4, 15 Temmuz: s. 290-295. google scholar
  • AĞAOĞLU, Ahmet, (1938d), “Türk Hukuk Tarihinde Usul”, İnsan, Yıl I, S. 1, 15 Nisan: s. 39-43. A google scholar
  • ĞAOĞLU, Ahmet, (2012), Ahmet Ağaoğlu ve Hukuk-ı Esasiye Ders Notları, 1926-1927, (Hazırlayan: Boğaç Erozan), İstanbul: Koç Üniversitesi Yayınları. google scholar
  • AĞAOĞLU, Əhməd, (2016), Sərbəst insanlar ölkəsində, Bakı: KitabKlubu.org. google scholar
  • AĞAOĞLU, Əhməd, (2017), Üç mədəniyyət, Bakı: KitabKlubu.org. google scholar
  • ASKER, Ali, YILDIZ, Canan ve ÖZKAN, Duygu, (2017), “Günümüz Penceresinden Ahmet Ağaoğlu “İslamiyetde Kadın” Eseri Üzerine Notlar”, II. Uluslararası Sosyal Bilimler Araştırmaları Kongresi Bildiri Kitabı, (Ed. H. Kara, T. Çetin, Y. İnel), Ankara: 40-50. google scholar
  • DAMİRLİ, Mehman, (2016), «Umumi (Genel) Türk Hukuk Tarihi̇: Konseptsel Sorunlar”, II. Türk Hukuk Tarihi Kongresi Bildirileri, (C. II), İstanbul: Onikilevha, 141-160. google scholar
  • KAYABAŞ, Ebru, (2012), ““Bir Yavuz Hukukçu”: Ahmet Ağaoğlu”, İÜHFM, C. LXX, S. 1: s. 441-452. google scholar
  • KİLİ, Suna, (1971), Assembly Debates on the Constitutions of 1924 and 1961, Istanbul: Robert College Research Center. google scholar
  • ÖZAVCI, Hilmi Ozan, (2015), İntellectual Origins of the Republic: Ahmet Ağaoğlu and the Genealogy of Liberalism in Turkey, Leyden, Boston: Brill. google scholar
  • SEYDİŞEHRİ, Mahmud Esad Efendi, (1331(1915)), Tarih-i İlm-i Hukuk, İstanbul: Matbaa-i Amire, google scholar
  • SEYDİŞEHRİ, Mahmud Esad Efendi, (2012a), Hukuk Tarihi (Tarih-i İlm-i Hukuk), İstanbul: Medhal İlmi Araştırma Derneği Yayınları. google scholar
  • SEYDİŞEHRİ, Mahmud Esad Efendi, (2012b), Tarih-i İlm-i Hukuk, İstanbul: Yetkin Yayınları. TBMM Albümü (1920-2010), (2010), C. I. (1920-1950), Ankara: TBMM Basın ve Halkla İlişkiler Müdürlüğü Yayınları No: 1. google scholar
  • YILMAZ, Murat, (1993), “Ahmet Ağaoğlu və Liberalizm Anlayışı”, Türkiyə Günlügü, 23/yaz: s. 56-71. google scholar
  • YÜCEL, M. Serhan, (2016), “Ankara Adliye Hukuk Mektebi’nin İlk Yili”, The Journal of Academic Social Science, Yıl IV, S. 26, Mart: s. 361-387. google scholar
  • АГАЕВ, Ахмед бек, (1901), Женщина по исламу и в исламе, Тифлис. google scholar
  • БАЛАЕВ, Айдын, (2018), Патриарх Тюркизма. Ахмет бек Агаоглу (1869-1939), Баку: Издательский дом ТЕАS Press. google scholar
  • ДАМИРЛИ, Мехман А., (2013), Сравнительное правоведение: Ч. 1. Статус, предмет и система, Одесса: Feniks. google scholar

Citations

Copy and paste a formatted citation or use one of the options to export in your chosen format


EXPORT



APA

Damirli, M. (2020). Ahmed bey Agaoglu: Portrait Traits of Identity as a Lawyer. Journal of Eurasian Inquiries, 9(2), 171-183. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.012


AMA

Damirli M. Ahmed bey Agaoglu: Portrait Traits of Identity as a Lawyer. Journal of Eurasian Inquiries. 2020;9(2):171-183. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.012


ABNT

Damirli, M. Ahmed bey Agaoglu: Portrait Traits of Identity as a Lawyer. Journal of Eurasian Inquiries, [Publisher Location], v. 9, n. 2, p. 171-183, 2020.


Chicago: Author-Date Style

Damirli, Mehman,. 2020. “Ahmed bey Agaoglu: Portrait Traits of Identity as a Lawyer.” Journal of Eurasian Inquiries 9, no. 2: 171-183. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.012


Chicago: Humanities Style

Damirli, Mehman,. Ahmed bey Agaoglu: Portrait Traits of Identity as a Lawyer.” Journal of Eurasian Inquiries 9, no. 2 (Apr. 2024): 171-183. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.012


Harvard: Australian Style

Damirli, M 2020, 'Ahmed bey Agaoglu: Portrait Traits of Identity as a Lawyer', Journal of Eurasian Inquiries, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 171-183, viewed 23 Apr. 2024, https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.012


Harvard: Author-Date Style

Damirli, M. (2020) ‘Ahmed bey Agaoglu: Portrait Traits of Identity as a Lawyer’, Journal of Eurasian Inquiries, 9(2), pp. 171-183. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.012 (23 Apr. 2024).


MLA

Damirli, Mehman,. Ahmed bey Agaoglu: Portrait Traits of Identity as a Lawyer.” Journal of Eurasian Inquiries, vol. 9, no. 2, 2020, pp. 171-183. [Database Container], https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.012


Vancouver

Damirli M. Ahmed bey Agaoglu: Portrait Traits of Identity as a Lawyer. Journal of Eurasian Inquiries [Internet]. 23 Apr. 2024 [cited 23 Apr. 2024];9(2):171-183. Available from: https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.012 doi: 10.26650/jes.2020.012


ISNAD

Damirli, Mehman. Ahmed bey Agaoglu: Portrait Traits of Identity as a Lawyer”. Journal of Eurasian Inquiries 9/2 (Apr. 2024): 171-183. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.012



TIMELINE


Submitted17.11.2019
Accepted09.09.2020
Published Online30.09.2020

LICENCE


Attribution-NonCommercial (CC BY-NC)

This license lets others remix, tweak, and build upon your work non-commercially, and although their new works must also acknowledge you and be non-commercial, they don’t have to license their derivative works on the same terms.


SHARE




Istanbul University Press aims to contribute to the dissemination of ever growing scientific knowledge through publication of high quality scientific journals and books in accordance with the international publishing standards and ethics. Istanbul University Press follows an open access, non-commercial, scholarly publishing.