CHAPTER


DOI :10.26650/B/SS52.2021.011.05   IUP :10.26650/B/SS52.2021.011.05    Full Text (PDF)

Eurasian Pivot in Russian and Turkish Foreign Policy: Eurasianism As an Ideational Premise?

Kamala Valiyeva

The main focus of the chapter is an examination of the issue of the Eurasian pivot in Russian and Turkish foreign policy. In doing so the chapter aims to determine the ideational and rational underpinnings of a substantial shift in foreign policy identity construction by concentrating on the question of whether Eurasianism constitutes an ideational premise of the Eurasian pivot. Another major question this chapter seeks to address is the strategic rationale behind the eastward shift. In this context, the chapter argues that the ideational foundation of the Eurasian pivot in both countries’ foreign policy is a fusion of two substantial elements of Eurasianism: anti-Westernism in combination with a post-imperial great power mindset (the discourse of “velikoderjavnost” and “neo-Ottomanism”). At the same time, it is not merely an ideational construction that drives such dynamics in foreign policy identity construction; it is also a pragmatic and rational interest that demands an instrumental use of the Eurasianist idea. In other words, what drives the Eurasian pivot and mutual rapprochement in this context is the need to acquire more effective maneuvering instruments and mechanisms with the aim to strengthen the international position against the West. Thus, Eurasianism in both countries’ Eurasia pivot discourse constitutes an instrumental approach.



References

  • ABD’nin Bile Çıkar Alanı Geniş Karadeniz Bölgesi Iken Türkiye’nin Asya Yönelimi Zorunluluktur [US Interests Even of The Wider Black Sea Region Of Turkey, While Asian Orientation Is A Necessity]. Sputnik. Retrieved from https://tr.sputniknews.com/columnists/201908081039881781-abdnin-bile-cikar-alani-genis-karadeniz-bolgesi-iken-turkiyenin-asya-yonelimi-zorunluluktur-yeniden-asya/ (Date of Access: 28.08.2019) google scholar
  • Akçalı, E. & Perinçek, M. (2009). Kemalist Eurasianism: An Emerging Geopolitical Discourse in Turkey. Geopolitics, 14(3), 550-569. google scholar
  • Akçura, Y. (2015). Üç Tarz-ı Siyaset [Three Styles of Politics]. Istanbul: Ötüken Neşriyat. google scholar
  • Akıllı, E. (2013). Turkey’s Illusions of Neo-Eurasianism and Interest in Shanghai Cooperation Organization. CESRAN International. Retrieved from https://cesran.org/turkeys-illusions-of-neo-eurasianismand-interest-inshanghai- cooperation-organization.html google scholar
  • Aktürk, Ş. (2015). The Fourth Style of Politics: Eurasianism as a Pro-Russian Rethinking of Turkey’s Geopolitical Identity. Turkish Studies, 16(1), 54-79. google scholar
  • Bassin, M. (2008). Eurasianism ‘Classical’ and ‘Neo’: The Lines of Continuity. Beyond the Empire: Images of Russia in the Eurasian Cultural Context. (Tetsuo Mochizuki ed.), Slavic Eurasian studies, No:17, Sapporo: Slavic Research Centre. google scholar
  • Bassin, M. (2015). Narrative Kulikovo. Lev Gumilev, Russian Nationalists, and the Troubled Emergence of Neo-Eurasianism. In Mark Bassin, Sergey Glebov, & Marlene Laruelle (Eds). Between Europe and Asia. The Origins, Theories, and Legacies of Russian Eurasianism. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press. google scholar
  • Bassin, M. (1991). Russia Between Europe and Asia: The Ideological Construction of Geographical Space. Slavic Review, 5^(1), 1-17. google scholar
  • Bassin, M., Glebov, S., Laruelle, M. (Eds). (2015). Between Europe and Asia: The Origins, Theories, and Legacies of Russian Eurasianism. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press. google scholar
  • Berdyaev, N. (1948). The Russian Idea. New York: Macmillan Company. google scholar
  • Bespalov, A. (2019). Povorot Rossii Na Vostok: Ojidaniya I Real’nost’. [Russia’s Turn to the East: Expectations and Realities]. Valdai. Retrieved from http://ru.valdaiclub.com/a/highlights/povorot-rossii-na-vostok-ozhidaniya-i-realnost/ google scholar
  • Cohen, F. S. (2018). Who Is Responsible for the New US-Russian Cold War? The Nation, Retrieved from https:// www.thenation.com/article/who-is-responsible-for-the-new-us-russian-cold-war/ google scholar
  • Çavuşoğlu, M. ‘Yeniden Asya’ Açılımını Duyurdu. [Çavuşoğlu Announced The ‘Asia Again’ Initiative].Yeni Şafak. Retrieved from https://www.yenisafak.com/dunya/yeniden-asya-acilimi-3501093 google scholar
  • Davutoğlu, A. (2011). Stratejik Derinlik. Türkiyenin Uluslararası Konumu [Strategic Depth. Turkey’s International Position]. İstanbul: Küre Yayınları. google scholar
  • Dugin, A. (2015). Last War of the World-Island. The Geopolitics of Contemporary Russia. London: Arktos google scholar
  • Dugin, A. (2000). Osnovı Geopolitiki [Foundations of Geopolitics]. Moskova, Rusya: Arktogeya. google scholar
  • Dugin, A. (2014). Eurasian Mission. An Introduction to Neo-Eurasianism. London, UK: Arktos. google scholar
  • Dutkevich, P. (2019). Rossia Pered Vizivami Evraziyskoy Regionalizatsii [Russia Facing the Challenges Of Eurasian Regionalization]. Valdai. Retrieved from http://ru.valdaiclub.com/a/highlights/rossiya-pered-vyzovami-evraziyskoy-regionalizatsii/ google scholar
  • Erşen, E. (2011). Turkey and Russia: An emerging ‘Strategic Axis’ in Eurasia? EurOrient, 35(36), 263-85. google scholar
  • Erşen, E. (2013). The Evolution of ‘Eurasia’ as a Geopolitical Concept in Post-Cold War Turkey. Geolpolitics, 18(1), 24-40. google scholar
  • Erşen, E. (2017 a). The Transatlantic Dimension of Turkey’s Strategic Rapprochement with Russia: The Turkish google scholar
  • Erşen, E. (2017 b). Geopolitical Traditions in Turkey: Turkish Eurasianism. In Bassin, M. & Pozo, G. (Ed.). The Politics of Eurasianism: Identity, Popular Culture and Russia’s Foreign Policy. London: Rowman and Littlefield. google scholar
  • Eurasia. In Mark Bassin, Sergey Glebov, & Marlene Laruelle (Eds). Between Europe and Asia. The Origins, Theories, and Legacies of Russian Eurasianism. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press. google scholar
  • Flockhart, T. (2016). The Coming Multi-Order World, Contemporary Security Policy, 37(1), 3-30. google scholar
  • Frappi, C. (2018). The Russo-Turkish Entente: A Tactical Embrace Along Strategic and Geopolitical Convergences. pp. 45-70. In Valeria Talbot (Ed) (2018), Turkey: Towards a Eurasian Shift? Milano: ISPI google scholar
  • Glebov, S. (2015). N. S. Trubetskoi’s Europe and Mankind and Eurasianist Antievolutionism. One Unknown Source. pp 48-67. In Mark Bassin, Sergey Glebov, & Marlene Laruelle (Eds). Between Europe and Asia. The Origins, Theories, and Legacies of Russian Eurasianism. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press google scholar
  • Gumilev, L. N. (2008). Ot Rusi do Rossii. Ocherki etnicheskoy istorii. [From Russia to Russia. Essays on Ethnic History]. Moscow: Ayris Press. google scholar
  • Güneş, A. (2012). Dilemmas of Eurasianism as an Alternative Policy for Turkey. International Journal of Turcologia, 7(14), 45-64 . google scholar
  • Imanbeyli, V. (2008). Klasik Avrasyacılık: Rus Medeniyet Kimliği İnşası. [Classical Eurasianism: Building a Russian Civilization Identity] Akademik Araştırmalar Dergisi, 35(1), 1-9. google scholar
  • Imanbeyli, V. (2015). ‘Failed Exodus’: Dugin’s Networks in Turkey. In M. Laruelle (Ed.) Eurasianism and the European Far Right: Reshaping the Europe- Russia Relationship. Lanham, MD: Lexington google scholar
  • In Mark Bassin, Sergey Glebov, & Marlene Laruelle (Eds) (2015). Between Europe and Asia. The Origins, Theories, and Legacies of Russian Eurasianism. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press google scholar
  • İsmayılov, M. (2011). Avrasyacılık: Mukayeseli Bir Okuma: Türkiye ve Rusya Örneği. [Eurasianism: A Comparative Reading: The Case of Turkey and Russia] Ankara: Doğu Batı Yayınları. google scholar
  • Karaganov, S. (2018 b). K Velikomu Okeanu. [To the great ocean] Izvestiya.https://iz.ru/784883/sergeikaraganov/ kvelikomu-okeanu google scholar
  • Karaganov, S. (2015). Evroaziatskii Vykhod Iz Evropeiskogo Krizisa. [Eurasian Way Out of the European Crisis]. Russia in Global Affairs. Retrieved from https://globalaffairs.ru/number/Evroaziatskii-vykhod-iz-evropeiskogo-krizisa-17641 Karaganov, S. (2017). Ot povorota na Vostok k Bolshoi Evrazii. [From Eastward Shift to Greater Eurasia]. Russia in Global Affairs. Retrieved from https://globalaffairs.ru/pubcol/ Ot-povorota-na-Vostok-k-Bolshoi-Evrazii-18739 google scholar
  • Karaganov, S. (2018 a). My İscherpali Evropeyskuyu Kladovuyu. [We Have Run Out of European Pantry]. Kommersant. Retrieved from https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/3719327 google scholar
  • Karaganov, S. (2019). The New Cold War and The Emerging Greater Eurasia. google scholar
  • Karasar, H. A. (2008). Türk Dış Politikasında Batı’ya Alternatif Arayışları: Avrasyacılık Örneği. [Seeking an Alternative to the West in Turkish Foreign Policy: The Case of Eurasianism] Demokrasi Platformu, 4(13), 117-128. google scholar
  • Karpat, K. (2004). Studies on Turkish Politics and Society, Leiden: Koninklijke Brill NV google scholar
  • Khlebnikov, A. (2018). A Russian Pivot to Asia? The National Interest, Retrieved from https://nationalinterest. org/feature/russian-pivot-asia-34892 google scholar
  • Kissinger, H. (2014). World Order. Penguin Press: New York. google scholar
  • Kortunov, A. (2016). Seven Phantoms of the Russia’s Policy toward the European Union. google scholar
  • Krauthammer, C. (1990). The Unipolar Moment. Foreign Affairs, 70(1), 23-33. google scholar
  • Laruelle, M. (2008). Russian Eurasianism: An Ideology of Empire. Washington DC: Woodrow Wilson Center Press. google scholar
  • Laruelle, M. (2015a). Postface. The Paradoxical Legacy of Eurasianism in Contemporary google scholar
  • Laruelle, M. (2015b). Conceiving the Territory. Eurasianism as a Geographical Ideology. Pp. 68-83. google scholar
  • Lewis, D. (2018). Geopolitical Imaginaries in Russian Foreign Policy: The Evolution of ‘Greater Eurasia’. Europe-Asia Studies, 70(10), 1612-1637. google scholar
  • Lisanin, M. (2017). Possibilities of Assessing the Changing Nature of International Politics in the Coming Multi-Order World. Croatian Political Science Review, 54(4), 143-160. google scholar
  • Macaes, B. (2018). The Dawn of Eurasia. On the Trail of the New World Order. Yale Univeristy Press; New Haven and London. google scholar
  • Mankoff, J. (2015). Russia’s Asia Pivot: Confrontation or Cooperation? Asia Policy, 19(1), 65-88. google scholar
  • Miller, A. & Lukyanov, F. (2018). Otstranennost Vmesto Konfrontatsii: Post-Evropeyskaya Rossiya V Poiskah Samoidentichnosti. [Detachment Instead of Confrontation: Post-European Russia In Search Of Self-Identity] Russian Council on Foreign and Defense Policy. Retrieved from http://svop.ru/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/ miller_lukyanov_rus.pdf google scholar
  • Morozova, N. (2009). Geopolitics, Eurasianism and Russian Foreign Policy Under Putin. Geopolitics, 14(4), 667-686. google scholar
  • Ot Lissabona Do Singapura: Poisk Tochek Soprikosnoveniya V Evrazii 21 Veka [From Lisbon To Singapore: Searching for Common Grounds In 21st Century Eurasia] Valdai. September 2017. http://ru.valdaiclub.com/ events/posts/articles/ot-lissabona-do-singapura-evraziya-xxi-veka/ google scholar
  • Öniş, Z. & Kutlay, M. (2017). Global Shifts and the Limits of the EU’s in the European Periphery: Comparative Perspectives from Hungary and Turkey. Government and Opposition, 54(2), 226-253. google scholar
  • Paderina, S. (2019). Da, Yevraziytsy - Mi? Povorot Rossii K Vostoku Za Natsional’noy Identichnost’yu.[Yes, Eurasians - Are We? The Turn of Russia To The East For National Identity] Russian Council On Foreign Affairs. Retrieved from https://russiancouncil.ru/analytics-and-comments/columns/postsoviet/da-evraziytsy-my-povorot-rossii-k-vostoku-za-natsionalnoy-identichnostyu/?sphrase_id=31449146 google scholar
  • Paikin, Z. (2019). Novaya Paradigma Dlya Bolşoy Evrazii. [New Paradigm for Greater Eurasia]. Russian Council on Foreign Affairs. Retrieved from https://russiancouncil.ru/analytics-and-comments/analytics/novaya-paradigma-dlya-bolshoy-evrazii/ google scholar
  • Perspective. pp. 203-216. In Sasha Toperich, Aylin Ünver Noi (Eds). Turkey and Transatlantic Relations. Washington, DC: Center for Transatlantic Relations. google scholar
  • Putin, V.V. (2005). Speech at the Meeting Dedicated to The 1000th Anniversary of Kazan. Retrieved from http:// www.kremlin.ru/events/president/transcripts/23138 google scholar
  • Putin, V.V. (2007). Speech at the meeting dedicated to the 450th anniversary of the entry of Bashkiria into Russia. Retrieved from http://www.kremlin.ru/events/president/transcripts/24590 google scholar
  • Putin, V.V. (2017). International Forum “One Belt, One Road”. Retrieved from http://www.kremlin.ru/events/ president/news/54491 google scholar
  • Rolland, N. (2019). A China-Russia Condominium over Eurasia. Survival: Global Politics and Strategy, 61(1), 7-22. google scholar
  • Romanova, T. (2018). Russia’s Neo-revisionist Challenge to the Liberal International Order. The International Spectator, 53(1), 76-91. google scholar
  • Russian International Affairs Council. Retrieved from http://russiancouncil.ru/en/analytics-and-comments/ analytics/sem-fantomov-rossiyskoy-politiki-v-otnoshenii-es/ google scholar
  • Sakwa, R. (2015). Frontline Ukraine: Crisis in the Borderlands. London: I. B. Tauris google scholar
  • Shlapentokh, D. (2015). The Ideological Framework of Early Post-Soviet Russia’s Relationship with Turkey: The Case of Alexander Dugin’s Eurasianism. Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies, 18(3), 263-281. google scholar
  • Stent, A. (2008). Reluctant Europeans: Three Centuries of Russian Ambivalence toward the West. pp. 393-441. In Robert Legvold (Ed). Russian Foreign Policy in the Twenty-First Century and the Shadow of the Past. New York: Columbia University Press. google scholar
  • Svarin, D. (2015). Towards a Eurasian Axis? Russia And Turkey Between Cooperation and Competition. Global Affairs, 1(4-5), 381-398. google scholar
  • Tanrısever, O. (2018). Discourses and Politics of Eurasianism in Turkey During The 2000s. pp. 13-34. In Valeria Talbot (Ed), Turkey: Towards a Eurasian Shift? Milano: ISPI. google scholar
  • Tellal, E. (2005). Türk Dış Politikasında Avrasya Seçeneği.[ Eurasian Option in Turkish Foreign Policy] Uluslararası İlişkiler, 2(5). 49-70. google scholar
  • Timofeev, I. (2018). Unbalanced Europe and the New Order in the OSCE Space. Moscow: Valdai Discussion Club. google scholar
  • Tolz, V. (2015). The Eurasians and Liberal Scholarship of the Late Imperial Period Continuity and Change across the 1917 Divide. 27-47 In Mark Bassin, Sergey Glebov, & Marlene Laruelle (Eds). Between Europe and Asia. The Origins, Theories, and Legacies of Russian Eurasianism. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press. google scholar
  • Torbakov, I. (2015). Becoming Eurasian The Intellectual Odyssey of Georgii Vladimirovich Vernadsky. In Mark Bassin, Sergey Glebov, & Marlene Laruelle (Eds). Between Europe and Asia. The Origins, Theories, and Legacies of Russian Eurasianism. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press. google scholar
  • Torbakov, I. (2017). Neo-Ottomanism versus Neo-Eurasianism?: Nationalism and Symbolic Geography in Postimperial Turkey and Russia. Mediterranean Quarterly, 28(2), 125-145. google scholar
  • Toward the Great Ocean - 6: People, History, Ideology, Education. Rediscovering the Identity, Valdai, 2018 Retrieved from http://valdaiclub.com/files/19357/ google scholar
  • Trenin, D. (2017). Russia’s Evolving Grand Eurasia Strategy: Will It Work? Moscow: Carnegie Moscow Center. google scholar
  • Trenin, D. (2013). Russia and the Rise of Asia. Moscow: Carnegie Moscow Center google scholar
  • Trenin, D. (2014). Russia’s Breakout from the Post-Cold War System. The Drivers of Putin’s Course. Carnegie google scholar
  • Moscow Center, Retrieved from http://carnegieendowment.org/files/CP_Trenin_Putin2014_web_Eng.pdf google scholar
  • Trenin, D. (2015). From Greater Europe to Greater Asia? The Sino-Russian Entente, Carnegie Moscow Center, Retrieved from http://carnegie.ru/2015/04/09/from-greater-europe-to-greater-asia-sinorussian-entente-pub-59728 google scholar
  • Trenin, D. (2016). Should We Fear Russia? Cambridge: Politic Press. google scholar
  • Tüfekçi, Ö. (2012). Another Last Eurasianist: Davutoglu’s Eurasianist Rhetoric. Caucasus International, 2(3), 101-109. google scholar
  • Tüysüzolu, G. (2014). Strategic Depth: A Neo-Ottomanist Interpretation of Turkish Eurasianism. Mediterranean Quarterly, 25(2), 86-104. google scholar
  • Valdai. (2015, June). ‘Toward the Great Ocean-3: Creating Central Eurasia: The Silk Road Economic Belt and the Priorities of the Eurasian States’ Joint Development’. Valdai Discussion Club, Retrieved from: http:// valdaiclub.com/a/reports/toward_the_great_ocean_3_creating_central_eurasia/ google scholar
  • Valiyeva, K. (2018). Central Asia at the Crossroads of Russian-Turkish Cooperation and Competition. pp. 181202. In Askarov A. (Ed.). Contemporary Russo-Turkish Relations: From Crisis to Cooperation. Maryland: Lexington Books. google scholar
  • Vinokurov, E. (2013). Pragmaticheskoye Evraziystvo. [Pragmatic Eurasianism]. Russia in Global Affairs. google scholar
  • Retrieved from https://globalaffairs.ru/number/Pragmaticheskoe-evraziistvo-15950 google scholar
  • Wiederkehr, S. (2007). Eurasianism as a Reaction to Pan-Turkism. pp 39-60. In Dmitry Shlapentokh (Ed). Russia between East and West. Scholarly Debates on Eurasianism. Leiden-Boston: Brill. google scholar
  • Zagorski, A. (2008). Multilateralism in Russian Foreign Policy Approaches. In Rowe, E.W. & Torjesen, S. (Eds). The Multilateral Dimension in Russian Foreign Policy. London: Routledge. google scholar


SHARE




Istanbul University Press aims to contribute to the dissemination of ever growing scientific knowledge through publication of high quality scientific journals and books in accordance with the international publishing standards and ethics. Istanbul University Press follows an open access, non-commercial, scholarly publishing.