Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul

SUBMITINFORMATION
EnglishTürkçe

Research Article


DOI :10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007   IUP :10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007    Full Text (PDF)

Recent Developments on the Question of Religion Courses: An Analysis of a Turkish Constitutional Courts’s Decision in 2022

Tolga Şirin

In this study, the decision of the Turkish Constitutional Court in 2022 regarding the compulsory religion classes, Hüseyin El and Nazlı Şirin El, was analyzed. The decision was criticized on the following eight points: (1) Although the correct decision was quite apparent, the Constitutional Court found a violation by only one vote. It created an unsafe situation. (2) The Constitutional Court established the violation too late. It weakened the objective effect of the decision. (3) The Constitutional Court referred to crucial international materials but did not consider their merits. (4) The Constitutional Court based its decision on the violation with reference to the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights but it missed the chance to make a much deeper analysis. (5) The Constitutional Court ignored the original and alternative theses in Turkish literature. (6) The Constitutional Court made controversial inferences regarding the principle of laicism, especially in the context of the doctrine of positive obligations. (7) The Ministry of Justice misrepresented the European Court of Human Rights judgments. (8) The application was not prepared professionally and powerfully enough.

Keywords: Turkish Constitutional Court, European Court of Human Rights, Compulsory Religion Course, Religious Culture and Moral Knowledge, Secularism

PDF View

References

  • Akbulut O and Usal Z O. ‘Parental Religious Rights vs. Compulsory Religious Education in Turkey’ (2008) 15 Int. J. Minor. Group Rights 433-455. google scholar
  • Akbulut O. ‘Turkey’s Reaction to the Judgments of the European Court of Human Rights’ (2015) 5 Int J Multidiscip 75-86. google scholar
  • Çınar Ö H. ‘An Unsolved Issue: Religious Education in International Human Rights Law and Case of Turkey’ in Mine Yıldırım and Özgür Heval Çınar (eds), Freedom of Religion and Belief in Turkey (CSP 2014) 57-79. google scholar
  • Çınar, Ö H. ‘Compulsory Religious Education in Turkey’ (2013) 8 Religion & Human Rights 223-241. google scholar
  • Esen S and Gönenç L. ‘Religious Information on Identity Cards: A Turkish Debate’ (2008) 23(2) JLR 579-603. google scholar
  • Özenç B. ‘The Religion Box on Identity Cards as a Means to Understand the Turkish Type of Secularism’ in in Mine Yıldırım and Özgür Heval Çınar (eds), Freedom of Religion and Belief in Turkey (CSP 2014) 89-112. google scholar
  • Özgül C. ‘Freedom of Religion, the ECtHR and Grassroots Mobilization on Religious Education in Turkey’ (2019) 12(1) Politics and Religion 101-133. google scholar
  • Şirin T. ‘Nüfus Cüzdanındaki Din Hanesi ve Eğitimdeki Din Dersi Zorlamalarına İlişkin Güncel Gelişmeler’ (2016) 149 Güncel Hukuk 21-26. google scholar
  • Yıldırım M. ‘Are Turkey’s Restrictions on Freedom of Religion or Belief Permissible?’ (2020) Religion & Human Rights 172-191. google scholar
  • ECtHR’s Decisions google scholar
  • Folgerø et al. v Norway App no. 15472/02 (ECtHR, 29 June 2007) google scholar
  • Hasan and Eylem Zengin v Turkey App no 1448/04 (ECtHR, 09 October 2007) google scholar
  • Kapmaz v Turkey App no 13716/12, (ECtHR, 07 January 2020) google scholar
  • Mansur Yalçın v. Turkey App no 21163/11 (ECtHR, 16 September 2014) google scholar
  • Osmanoğlu and Kocabaş v Switzerland App no. 29086/12 (ECtHR, 10 January 2017) google scholar
  • Sinan Işık v Turkey App no 21924/05 (ECtHR 02 February 2010) google scholar
  • Valsamis v Greece App no. 21787/93 (ECtHR, 18 December 1996) google scholar
  • TCC’s Decisions google scholar
  • Cem Sarısülük and others App no. 2015/16451 (TCC, 15 December 2021) google scholar
  • Durmuş Fikri Sağlar (2) App no. 2017/29735 (TCC, 17 March 2021) google scholar
  • Gülistan Atasoy and others App no. 2017/15845, (TCC, 21 January 2021) google scholar
  • Hüseyin El ve Nazlı Şirin El App no 2014/15345 (TCC, 07 April 2022) google scholar
  • Mehmet Osman Kavala (2) App no. 2020/13893 (TCC, 29 December 2020) google scholar
  • Müyesser Uğur App no. 2020/18546 (TCC, 07 April 2022) google scholar
  • Umut Çongar App no. 2017/36905 (TCC, 21 October 2021) google scholar
  • Yasin Agin and others App no. 2017/32534, (TCC, 21 January 2021) google scholar
  • E. 1997/62, K. 1998/52, (TCC, 16 September 1998) google scholar
  • E. 2012/65, K. 2012/128 (TCC, 20 September 2012) google scholar
  • E. 2012/65, K. 2012/128 (TCC, 20 September 2012) google scholar

Citations

Copy and paste a formatted citation or use one of the options to export in your chosen format


EXPORT



APA

Şirin, T. (2022). Recent Developments on the Question of Religion Courses: An Analysis of a Turkish Constitutional Courts’s Decision in 2022. Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, 0(71), 481-496. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007


AMA

Şirin T. Recent Developments on the Question of Religion Courses: An Analysis of a Turkish Constitutional Courts’s Decision in 2022. Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul. 2022;0(71):481-496. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007


ABNT

Şirin, T. Recent Developments on the Question of Religion Courses: An Analysis of a Turkish Constitutional Courts’s Decision in 2022. Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, [Publisher Location], v. 0, n. 71, p. 481-496, 2022.


Chicago: Author-Date Style

Şirin, Tolga,. 2022. “Recent Developments on the Question of Religion Courses: An Analysis of a Turkish Constitutional Courts’s Decision in 2022.” Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul 0, no. 71: 481-496. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007


Chicago: Humanities Style

Şirin, Tolga,. “Recent Developments on the Question of Religion Courses: An Analysis of a Turkish Constitutional Courts’s Decision in 2022.” Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul 0, no. 71 (Sep. 2025): 481-496. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007


Harvard: Australian Style

Şirin, T 2022, 'Recent Developments on the Question of Religion Courses: An Analysis of a Turkish Constitutional Courts’s Decision in 2022', Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, vol. 0, no. 71, pp. 481-496, viewed 20 Sep. 2025, https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007


Harvard: Author-Date Style

Şirin, T. (2022) ‘Recent Developments on the Question of Religion Courses: An Analysis of a Turkish Constitutional Courts’s Decision in 2022’, Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, 0(71), pp. 481-496. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007 (20 Sep. 2025).


MLA

Şirin, Tolga,. “Recent Developments on the Question of Religion Courses: An Analysis of a Turkish Constitutional Courts’s Decision in 2022.” Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, vol. 0, no. 71, 2022, pp. 481-496. [Database Container], https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007


Vancouver

Şirin T. Recent Developments on the Question of Religion Courses: An Analysis of a Turkish Constitutional Courts’s Decision in 2022. Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul [Internet]. 20 Sep. 2025 [cited 20 Sep. 2025];0(71):481-496. Available from: https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007 doi: 10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007


ISNAD

Şirin, Tolga. “Recent Developments on the Question of Religion Courses: An Analysis of a Turkish Constitutional Courts’s Decision in 2022”. Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul 0/71 (Sep. 2025): 481-496. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2022.71.0007



TIMELINE


Submitted05.09.2022
Accepted05.11.2022
Published Online09.12.2022

LICENCE


Attribution-NonCommercial (CC BY-NC)

This license lets others remix, tweak, and build upon your work non-commercially, and although their new works must also acknowledge you and be non-commercial, they don’t have to license their derivative works on the same terms.


SHARE




Istanbul University Press aims to contribute to the dissemination of ever growing scientific knowledge through publication of high quality scientific journals and books in accordance with the international publishing standards and ethics. Istanbul University Press follows an open access, non-commercial, scholarly publishing.