Research Article


DOI :10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012   IUP :10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012    Full Text (PDF)

Models of Criminal Liability of a Plurality of Perpetrators under Polish and German Criminal Law: Comparative Approach

Aleksandra MiśkiewiczAlexander Vadokas

Polish-German history goes back centuries. The long-lasting relationship of the two countries also becomes apparent looking at their regimes of criminal liability as a perpetrator. The article presents these models focusing on the phenomenon of cooperation of criminals of more than one perpetrator. The purpose of this study is to consider coperpetration as a form of committing a prohibited act. The article seeks to capture the entirety of criminal lawlessness of committing prohibited acts in the form of co-perpetration and perpetration by means, through the analysis of the currently functioning regulations of the Polish and German Criminal Codes and their comparative approach, as well as determining the scope of legal liability in this regard. An analysis of the possibility of liability for committing a prohibited act in the form of co-perpetration in the light of philosophical and psychological concepts of criminal law was also carried out. The article also presents a historical analysis of Polish and German regulations in the field of criminal liability. The article presents a historical analysis of Polish and German regulations in the field of criminal liability for committing a crime in the form of complicity, based mainly on the post-partition and post-war history of Poland. Due to their common heritage to the Prussian Landrecht and criminal code as well as Feuerbach’s Bavarian Criminal Code, it is proved that the models of criminal liability of a plurality of perpetrators under Polish and German criminal law share many similarities.


PDF View

References

  • Bardach J, Historia Ustroju i Prawa Polskiego (LexisNexis 2005) google scholar
  • Bardach J, Lesnodorski B and Pietrzak M, Historia Ustroju i Prawa Polskiego (LexisNexis 2009) google scholar
  • Becker C, Das Gemeinschaftliche Begehen Und Die Sogenannte Additive Mittaterschaft (2008) google scholar
  • Bloy R, ‘Grenzen Der Taterschaft Bei Fremdhandiger Tatausführung’ [1996] Goltdammer’s Archiv für Strafrecht 424 google scholar
  • Bohlander M, The German Criminal Code: A Modern English Translation (Hart Publishing 2008) google scholar
  • Buchala K, Polskie Prawo Karne (PWN 1997) google scholar
  • Dierlamm A, ‘Anmerkung Zu BGH, NStZ 1998, 568’ [1998] Neue Zeitschrift für Strafrecht 569 google scholar
  • Eisele J, ‘Strafrecht AT: Abgrenzung von Mittaterschaft Und Beihilfe’ [2020] Juristische Schulung 1081 google scholar
  • Eser A and Sternberg-Lieben D, ‘§ 212 StGB’ in Albin Eser (ed), Schönke/Schröder (30th edn, CH Beck) google scholar
  • Fischer T, Strafgesetzbuch Mit Nebengesetzen (70th edn, 2023) google scholar
  • Gardocki L, Prawo Karne (CH Beck 2021) google scholar
  • Geppert K, ‘Die Mittaterschaft (§ 25 Abs. 2 StGB)’ [2011] Juristische Ausbildung 30 google scholar
  • ‘German Penal Code of 15.05.1871 in the Adaption of 13.11.1998 (BGBl I S 3322), Last Amended by Art 4 of the Act to Amend the Federal Central Register and the Penal Code of 04.12.2022 (BGBl I S 2146)’ google scholar
  • Giezek J, Kodeks Karny. Czçsc Ogölna. Komentarz 1.1 (Art. 1-31) (2000) google scholar
  • Heine G and WeiBer B, ‘§ 25 StGB’ in Albin Eser (ed), Schönke/Schröder (30th edn, CH Beck) google scholar
  • ——, ‘Vor. §§ 25ff StGB’ in Albin Eser (ed), Schönke/Schröder (30th edn, CH Beck) google scholar
  • Jakobs G, ‘Mittelbare Taterschaft Der Mitglieder Des Nationalen Verteidigungsrats’ [1995] Neue Zeitschrift für Strafrecht 26 google scholar
  • Joecks W and Scheinfeld J, ‘§ 25 StGB’ in Volker Erb and Jürgen Schafer (eds), Münchener Kommentar, vol 1 (4th edn, CH Beck) google scholar
  • — —, ‘§ 29 StGB’ in Volker Erb and Jürgen Schafer (eds), Münchener Kommentar, vol 1 (4th edn, CH Beck) google scholar
  • — —, ‘Vor § 25 StGB’ in Volker Erb and Jürgen Schafer (eds), Münchener Kommentar, vol 1 (4th edn, CH Beck) google scholar
  • — —, ‘Vor § 26 StGB’ in Volker Erb and Jürgen Schafer (eds), Münchener Kommentar, vol 1 (4th edn, CH Beck) google scholar
  • Kardas P, ‘Przypisanie Skutku Przy Przestçpnym Wspöldzialaniu’ [2004] Ptveglad Prawa Publicznego nr 4 google scholar
  • ----, ‘Sprawstwo Kierownicze i Polecajace - Wykonawcze Czy Niewykonawcze Postaci Sprawstwa?’ [2006] Przeglad. Sadowv nr 5 google scholar
  • Kinzig J, ‘§ 46 StGB’ in Albin Eser (ed), Schönke/Schröder (30th edn, CH Beck) google scholar
  • Koch, ‘Grundlagen Zur Mittelbaren Taterschaft, § 25 I Alt 2’ [2008] Juristische Schulung 496 google scholar
  • Korte M, ‘§ 339 StGB’ in Volker Erb and Jürgen Schafer (eds),MünchenerKommentar, vol 6 (4th edn, CH Beck) google scholar
  • Kühl K, ‘Taterschaft Und Teilnahme’ [2014] Juristische Arbeitsblatter 668 google scholar
  • ——, Strafrecht Allgemeiner Teil (8th edn, Verlag Franz Vahlen 2017) google scholar
  • Liszewska A, Wsp61dzialanie Przestçpcze w Polskim Prawie Karnym. Analiza Dogmatyczna (2004) google scholar
  • Makarewicz J, Kodeks Karny z Komentarzem (1938) google scholar
  • Marek A, Prawo Karne (Beck 2009) google scholar
  • Murmann U, ‘Grundwissen Zur Mittelbaren Taterschaft (§ 25 I 2. Alt. StGB)’ [2008] Juristische Arbeitsblatter 321 google scholar
  • Otto H, ‘Taterschaft, Mittelbare Taterschaft Und Mittaterschaft’ [1987] Juristische Ausbildung 246 google scholar
  • Peters K and Bildner A, ‘Die Mittaterschaft Gem. § 25 II StGB Und Ihre Herausforderungen in Der Fallbearbeitung’ [2020] Juristische Schulung 731 google scholar
  • Puppe I, ‘Wie Wird Man Mittater Durch Konkludentes Verhalten? (NStZ 1991, 571)’ [1991] Neue Zeitschrift für Strafrecht 571 google scholar
  • Radde L, ‘Von Mauerschützen Und Schreibtischtatern - Die Mittelbare Taterschaft Kraft Organisationsherrschaft Und Ihre Anwendung Auf Wirtschaftsunternehmen de Lege Lata’ [2018] Juristische Ausbildung 1210 google scholar
  • Rengier R, ‘Taterschaft Und Teilnahme - Unverandert Aktuelle Streitpunkte’ [2010] Juristische Schulung 281 google scholar
  • ——, Strafrecht Allgemeiner Teil (14th edn, CH Beck 2022) google scholar
  • Rönnau T, ‘Grundwissen - Strafrecht: Der „Tater Hinter Dem Tater“’ [2021] Juristische Schulung 923 google scholar
  • ——, ‘Grundwissen - Strafrecht: Drei- Oder Zweistufiger Verbrechensaufbau?’ [2021] Juristische Schulung 499 google scholar
  • Rotsch T, ‘Die Rechtsfigur Des Taters Hinter Dem Tater Bei Der Begehung von Straftaten Im Rahmen Organisatorischer Machtapparate Und Ihre Übertragbarkeit Auf Wirtschaftliche Organisationsstrukturen’ [1998] Neue Zeitschrift für Strafrecht 491 google scholar
  • Roxin C, ‘Straftaten Im Rahmen Organisatorischer Machtapparate’ [1963] Goltdammer’s Archiv für Strafrecht 193 google scholar
  • ——, ‘Anmerkung Zu BGHSt 40, 218’ [1995] Juristenzeitung 49 google scholar
  • ——, Strafrecht Allgemeiner Teil Band II - Besondere Erscheinungsformen Der Straftat (CH Beck 2003) google scholar
  • ----, Taterschaft Und Tatherrschaft (Elfte Auflage, De Gruyter 2022) <https://katalog.ub.uni-freiburg.de/link?kid=1794641343> google scholar
  • Roxin C and Greco L, Strafrecht Allgemeiner Teil Band I Grundlagen - Der Aufbau Der Verbrechenslehre (CH Beck 2020) google scholar
  • Satzger H, ‘Die Eigenhandigen Delikte’ [2011] Juristische Ausbildung 103 google scholar
  • Schmitz R, ‘§ 242 StGB’ in Volker Erb and Jürgen Schafer (eds), Münchener Kommentar, vol 4 (4th edn, CH Beck) google scholar
  • Schroeder F-C, Der Tater Hinter Dem Tater. Ein Beitrag Zur Lehre von Der Mittelbaren Taterschaft (Duncker & Humblot 1965) google scholar
  • Schünemann B, ‘Die Rechtsfigur Des „Taters Hinter Dem Tater“ Und Das Prinzip Der Tatherrschaftsstufen’ [2006] Zeitschrift für internationale Strafrechtsdogmatik 301 google scholar
  • Sternberg-Lieben D, ‘§ 223 StGB’ in Albin Eser (ed), Schönke/Schröder (30th edn, CH Beck) google scholar
  • ‘Ustawa z Dnia 6 Czerwca 1997 r - Kodeks Karny (Dz. U. z 2022 r Text No 1138).’ google scholar
  • ‘Ustawa z Dnia 19 Kwietnia 1969 r Kodeks Karny (Dz U 1969.13.94)’ google scholar
  • Valerius B, ‘Besondere Persönliche Merkmale’ [2013] Juristische Ausbildung 15 google scholar
  • Wessels J, Beulke W and Satzger H, Strafrecht Allgemeiner Teil (52nd edn, CF Müller 2022) google scholar
  • Wolter W, Nauka o Przestçpstwie (PWN 1973) google scholar
  • Wr6bel W and Zoll A, Polskie Prawo Karne. Czçsc Ogolna (Znak 2013) google scholar
  • BGH, BeckRS 2020, 10990, google scholar
  • BGH, JR 2004, 245, google scholar
  • BGH, NJW 2020, 2900, google scholar
  • BGH NStZ 1987, 364, google scholar
  • BGH NStZ 1998, 568, google scholar
  • BGH NStZ 2008, 89, google scholar
  • BGH, NStZ-RR 2016, 6, google scholar
  • BGHSt 16, 351, google scholar
  • BGHSt 28, 346, google scholar
  • BGHSt 37, 289, google scholar
  • BGHSt 40, 218, google scholar
  • BGHSt 48, 52, google scholar
  • Decision of the Supreme Court of Poland I K 736/36 of 20/03/1937 google scholar
  • Decision of the Supreme Court of Poland II KK 289/19 of 18/06/2020 google scholar
  • Decision of the Supreme Court of Poland IV KK 99/22 of 30/03/2022 google scholar
  • Decision of the Supreme Court of Poland IV KK 40620 of 15/10/2021 google scholar
  • Decision of the Supreme Court of Poland V KK 375/18 of 24/10/2018 google scholar
  • RGSt 3, 181, google scholar
  • RGSt 54, 177, google scholar
  • RGSt 58, 279, google scholar
  • RGSt 74, 84 google scholar

Citations

Copy and paste a formatted citation or use one of the options to export in your chosen format


EXPORT



APA

Miśkiewicz, A., & Vadokas, A. (2024). Models of Criminal Liability of a Plurality of Perpetrators under Polish and German Criminal Law: Comparative Approach. Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, 0(74), 271-305. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012


AMA

Miśkiewicz A, Vadokas A. Models of Criminal Liability of a Plurality of Perpetrators under Polish and German Criminal Law: Comparative Approach. Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul. 2024;0(74):271-305. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012


ABNT

Miśkiewicz, A.; Vadokas, A. Models of Criminal Liability of a Plurality of Perpetrators under Polish and German Criminal Law: Comparative Approach. Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, [Publisher Location], v. 0, n. 74, p. 271-305, 2024.


Chicago: Author-Date Style

Miśkiewicz, Aleksandra, and Alexander Vadokas. 2024. “Models of Criminal Liability of a Plurality of Perpetrators under Polish and German Criminal Law: Comparative Approach.” Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul 0, no. 74: 271-305. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012


Chicago: Humanities Style

Miśkiewicz, Aleksandra, and Alexander Vadokas. Models of Criminal Liability of a Plurality of Perpetrators under Polish and German Criminal Law: Comparative Approach.” Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul 0, no. 74 (Dec. 2024): 271-305. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012


Harvard: Australian Style

Miśkiewicz, A & Vadokas, A 2024, 'Models of Criminal Liability of a Plurality of Perpetrators under Polish and German Criminal Law: Comparative Approach', Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, vol. 0, no. 74, pp. 271-305, viewed 23 Dec. 2024, https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012


Harvard: Author-Date Style

Miśkiewicz, A. and Vadokas, A. (2024) ‘Models of Criminal Liability of a Plurality of Perpetrators under Polish and German Criminal Law: Comparative Approach’, Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, 0(74), pp. 271-305. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012 (23 Dec. 2024).


MLA

Miśkiewicz, Aleksandra, and Alexander Vadokas. Models of Criminal Liability of a Plurality of Perpetrators under Polish and German Criminal Law: Comparative Approach.” Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, vol. 0, no. 74, 2024, pp. 271-305. [Database Container], https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012


Vancouver

Miśkiewicz A, Vadokas A. Models of Criminal Liability of a Plurality of Perpetrators under Polish and German Criminal Law: Comparative Approach. Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul [Internet]. 23 Dec. 2024 [cited 23 Dec. 2024];0(74):271-305. Available from: https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012 doi: 10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012


ISNAD

Miśkiewicz, Aleksandra - Vadokas, Alexander. Models of Criminal Liability of a Plurality of Perpetrators under Polish and German Criminal Law: Comparative Approach”. Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul 0/74 (Dec. 2024): 271-305. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2024.74.0012



TIMELINE


Submitted03.08.2023
Accepted01.11.2023
Published Online15.04.2024

LICENCE


Attribution-NonCommercial (CC BY-NC)

This license lets others remix, tweak, and build upon your work non-commercially, and although their new works must also acknowledge you and be non-commercial, they don’t have to license their derivative works on the same terms.


SHARE




Istanbul University Press aims to contribute to the dissemination of ever growing scientific knowledge through publication of high quality scientific journals and books in accordance with the international publishing standards and ethics. Istanbul University Press follows an open access, non-commercial, scholarly publishing.