Research Article


DOI :10.26650/jes.2020.010   IUP :10.26650/jes.2020.010    Full Text (PDF)

National State Building, Islamic Policy and Regional Cooperation in Georgia during the Period of Independence

Ali AskerTuğba Ünal

One of the most important issues in the countries that have gained independence in the modern period is the successful implementation of the process of national state building. The implementation of this process directly depends on several elements. One of them is the element of religious identity, which is an important part of the national identity of citizens. The policy of religion and national (ethnic) minorities implemented by the states is of great importance in terms of the successful continuation of national state building. In Georgia, where various national, religious and ethnic groups live, this policy has its own problems. The implementation of the national policy on minorities within the framework of the general principles of human rights, democracy and international law is important in terms of eliminating these problems. The successful solution to the problems of Muslim minorities living in Georgia, consisting of Borchali Turks, Ajars, Akhisga Turks and Cysts, depends on the nature of Islamic policy in the country. The sociological survey conducted several times since 2011 and the results obtained have been very useful in terms of the preparation of this article. As well as a large number of researchers in 2015-2016, surveys, observations and indepth interviews, as well as scientific research in Turkey have allowed to successfully complete this article. The article draws attention to the role of trilateral cooperation in solving existing problems using the results obtained during the sociological surveys and research mentioned above, as well as the materials in official sources related to the region. 

DOI :10.26650/jes.2020.010   IUP :10.26650/jes.2020.010    Full Text (PDF)

Müstəqillik Dövründə Gürcüstanda Milli Dövlət Quruculuğu, İslam Siyasəti Və Regional Əməkdaşlıq

Ali AskerTuğba Ünal

Müasir dövrdə müstəqilliyini yeni qazanmış ölkələrdə ən önəmli məsələlərdən biri milli dövlət quruculuğu prosesinin uğurla həyata keçirilməsidir. Bu prosesin həyata keçirilməsi bilavasitə bir neçə ünsürdən asılıdır. Bunlardan biri vətəndaşların milli kimliklərinin önəmli bir parçasını təşkil edən dini kimlik ünsürüdür. Dövlətlərin həyata keçirdikləri dini və milli (etnik) azlıqlar siyasəti milli dövlət quruculuğunun uğurla davam etdirilməsi baxımından vacib əhəmiyyət kəsb edir. Müxtəlif milli, dini və etnik qrupların yaşadığı Gürcüstanda bu siyasətin özünəməxsus problemləri mövcuddur. Azlıqlarla bağlı milli siyasətin insan hüquqları, demokratiya və beynəlxalq hüququn ümumi prinsipləri çərçivəsində həyata keçirilməsi bu problemlərin aradan qaldırılması baxımından vacibdir. Gürcüstanda yaşayan Borçalı türkləri, acarlar, Axısqa türkləri və kistlərdən ibarət müsəlman azlıqlarla bağlı problemlərin uğurlu həlli ölkədəki islam siyasətinin xarakterindən asılıdır. 2011-ci ildən etibarən bir neçə dəfə aparılmış sosioloji sorğu və əldə edilən nəticələr bu məqalənin hazırlanması baxımından çox faydalı olmuşdur. Habelə 2015-2016-cı illərdə çox sayda araşdırmaçının yer aldığı kollektiv sorğu, müşahidə və dərin müsahibələr, habelə, Türkiyədəki elmi araşdırmalar bu məqaləni uğurla tamamlamağa imkan vermişdir. Məqalədə, yuxarıda bəhs edilən sosioloji sorğu və araşdırmalar zamanı əldə edilən nəticələrdən, habelə regionla bağlı rəsmi mənbələrdə yer alan materiallardan istifadə edilərək mövcud problemlərin həlli məsələsində üçtərəfli əməkdaşlığın roluna diqqət çəkilmişdir.


EXTENDED ABSTRACT


Georgia, which was occupied by Russia in the 19th century, existed as an independent republic in 1918-1921, and where the Soviet power was dominant starting from 1921, regained independence in 1991. After regaining independence, one of the most important issues in Georgia has been the issue of national/ethnic and religious minorities. Moreover, the privileges granted to the Georgian Church as well as the violation of the rights of Muslim minorities during this period are seriously criticized.

The most crowded population among the Muslims of Georgia is the Borchaly Turks. According to the argument of the Georgian historians, the Borchaly Turks were supposedly made to migrate to the region by Shah Abbas in the 17th century. This argument is wrong, and the researches confirm that Turks have lived in this region since very ancient times. The region known as Borchaly was included in the Kvemo Kartli region in line with the administrative region division made in Georgia after independence. In sectarian terms, an important part of the Borchaly Turks is Shia and the rest are Sunni. At present, there is not even one TurkishMuslim living in Armenia. The fact that Muslim minorities living in Georgia turn to different religious communities and sects reinforces the segregation in society. For example, there is Sunni-Shia segregation among the Borchaly Turks, albeit in small segments. While Salafism spreads strongly in the Kist community, the Salafi/Wahhabi movement may find supporters among the other Muslim groups of Georgia.

Another Muslim group living in Georgia are the Kists. The Kists mostly live in villages in the Pankisi Valley, in the northeast of Georgia, and have a strong traditional community structure. Today, the traditionalist-innovative discussions continue in the Kist community. The traditionalists are members of the Qadiriyya or Naqshbandi sect, which has existed in the Caucasus for a long time. The innovators are those who follow the Salafi/Wahhabi movement. This segregation has shown its effect on the Kist community, caused a serious transformation in the belief-based social structure, and also occasionally brought up the Pankisi Valley to the world agenda in the context of security issues. 

The Muslim minority that has the most serious identity problem in Georgia is the Adzhars. The tendency towards Christianization among the Adzhars is on the increase due to pressure or incentive. As a result of the religious policies of the Tbilisi administration following the collapse of the Soviet Union, there has been a substantial decrease in the number of Muslims in Adzharia. At this point, the Muslim Adzhars are a religious minority not only in Georgia but also in Adzharia.

One of the Muslim groups that constitute a minority in number in Georgia is the Meskhetian Turks. The Meskheti region was abandoned to the Russian Empire after the Ottoman-Russian wars, and remained within the Georgian borders during the period of the Soviet Union. In 1944, the Meskhetian Turks were exiled from their ancestral homeland to Central Asia. In 1956-1991, the Meskhetian Turks continued their struggle to return home and their organisation activities. One of the conditions of membership of Georgia to the Council of Europe in 1999 was to ensure the return of the Meskhetian Turks. However, this process failed, and very few Meskhetian Turks migrated to various regions of Georgia.

The issue of Muslim minority is one of the issues that are occasionally added to agenda and discussed in Turkey-Georgia and Azerbaijan-Georgia relations. Unfortunately, though the relations between Turkey and Georgia as well as the ones between Azerbaijan and Georgia have a strategic nature, there are still artificial phobias produced in Georgian society such as "threat of Turkey", "fear of Turk" and "economic expansionism of Azerbaijanis". The false propaganda of certain circles in Georgia and the wrong policies implemented by the Georgian administration on minorities in general play an important role in the emergence of this situation. It is observed that there are some efforts to dissolve these issues through bilateral negotiations (i.e., Turkey-Georgia and Azerbaijan-Georgia). On the other hand, thanks to the development of trilateral cooperation format which brings together all three states on the same platform today, it will be possible to dissolve the issues in a more optimal and faster way. Further development of the trilateral cooperation format is of great importance for the security, economic and social development of the region. Likewise, the meetings in the form of trilateral cooperation are held, and important documents such as the Trabzon Declaration of 8 June 2012, Batumi Communique of 28 March 2013 and Ganja Declaration of 19 February 2014 were adopted. The last of these meetings was held in Tbilisi on 23 December 2019. In face of the cooperation developed between Russia, Iran and Armenia, and including certain claims and threats against the countries in the region, it is extremely important to strengthen the cooperation line between Turkey, Azerbaijan and Georgia in terms of regional security and development. In line with the common interests of all three states, dissolution of the issues related to minorities, resolution of religious and ethnic disputes and settlement of problems in this area will be able to raise the Turkey-Azerbaijan-Georgia relations to the level of strategic cooperation in the true sense of the word.


PDF View

References

  • Asker Ali, Çoxtərəfli əməkdaşlıq prizmasından Türkiyənin Cənubi Qafqaz siyasəti, Qafqazşünasların Birinci Beynəlxalq Forumu [17-18 aprel 2017: Bakı], Azərbaycan MEA Qafqazşünaslıq İnstitutu, Bakı, 2017 (ss. 212-218). google scholar
  • Asker Ali, Kahraman Alter, Gürcistan’da Devletleşme, Kimlik İnşası ve Müslüman Topluluklar. İçinde: Gürcistan’daki Müslüman Topluluklar: Azınlık Hakları, Kimlik, Siyaset (Editörler: Ayşegül Aydıngün, Ali Asker, Aslan Yavuz Şir), AVİM Yay., Terazi Yayıncılık, Ankara 2016 (ss. 23-47). google scholar
  • Asker Ali, Öğütcü Özge Nur. Borçalı Türkleri: İslam, Mezhep ve Din Temelli Sorunlar, Gürcistan’da Müslüman Topluluklar: Azınlık Hakları, Kimlik, Siyaset (Ed. Ayşegül Aydıngün, Ali Asker, Aslan Yavuz Şir), Avrasya İncelemeleri Merkezi, Ankara 2016 (ss. 219-244). google scholar
  • Asker Ali. Gürcistan’da Din-Devlet İlişkilerinde Yeni Yasal Düzenleme, 21.Yüzyıl. Eylül, 2011, No. 33 (ss. 66-72). google scholar
  • Aydıngün Ayşegül, Asker Ali, Üner Anıl. Pankisi Vadisi’nde Kistler: Selefilik, Gelenekçilik, Kimlik ve Siyaset, Gürcistan’da Müslüman Topluluklar: Azınlık Hakları, Kimlik, Siyaset (Ed. Ayşegül Aydıngün, Ali Asker, Aslan Yavuz Şir), Avrasya İncelemeleri Merkezi, Ankara 2016 (ss. 347-370). google scholar
  • Bilestka Yuliya, Tuncel Turgut Kerem. Ahıska Türklerinin Gürcistan’a Geri Dönüşü ve ‘Ermeni Faktörü’, Gürcistan’da Müslüman Topluluklar: Azınlık Hakları, Kimlik, Siyaset (Ed. Ayşegül Aydıngün, Ali Asker, Aslan Yavuz Şir), Avrasya İncelemeleri Merkezi, Ankara 2016 (ss. 319-346). google scholar
  • Çelikpala Mitat, Veliyev Cavid. Azerbaycan-Gürcistan-Türkiye. Bölgesel İşbirliğinin Başarılı Örneği, Polisy Brief, Center for International and European Studies (CIES) , Marty 2015. Huseynov Rashad, History and Evolution of Islamic Institutions in Azerbaijan (XIX-XXI. Centuries). The Caucasus - Globalization Journal of Social, Political and Economic Studies. Vol. 8, Issue 1-2, 2014 (pp. 1-11). google scholar
  • İsgəndərov Anar, Mövlayi Adil, Şeyxülislamın tarixi, “Elm və təhsil”, Bakı 2016. google scholar
  • Kahraman Alter, Katliarou Yury, Anaç Özge. Müslüman Acarlılar: İslam, Din Değiştirme ve Dini Haklar, Gürcistan’da Müslüman Topluluklar: Azınlık Hakları, Kimlik, Siyaset (Ed. Ayşegül Aydıngün, Ali Asker, Aslan Yavuz Şir), Avrasya İncelemeleri Merkezi, Ankara 2016 (ss.159-1992). google scholar
  • Məmmədov Ceyhun, Azərbaycan Xalq Cümhuriyyəti dövründə dövlət-din münasibətləri, Dövlət və Din, № 04 (51) iyul - avqust 2017, (ss. 6-15). google scholar
  • National Statistics Office of Georgia “2014 General Population Census-Population by Regions and Religion”, http://www.census.ge/en/results/census (20.05.2016). google scholar
  • No:410/19, Azərbaycan Respublikası, Gürcüstan və Türkiyə Respublikasının Xarici İşlər nazirlərinin Səkkizinci Üçtərəfli Görüşü, Tbilisi Bəyənatı, 23.12.2019, http://mfa.gov.az/az/news/6510/pno41019-azerbaycanrespublikasi- guumlrcuumlstan-ve-tuumlrkiye-respublikasinin-xarici-isler-nazirlerinin-sekkizinciuumlccedilterefli- goumlruumlsuuml-tbilisi-beyenatip [Baxıldığı tarix: 12.03.2020]. google scholar
  • Prasad Conor. Georgia’s Muslim Community: A Self-Fulfilling Prophecy? ECMI Working Paper. No. 58, 2012. google scholar
  • Митрополит Батумский Димитрий – о чуде в Аджарии, мусульманах и Патриархе Илии, http://www. pravmir.ru/mitropolit-batumskij-i-lazskij-dimitrij-adzhariya-vernulas-k-istokam/, 06.12.2012, [Baxıldığı tarix: 20.05.2017]. google scholar

Citations

Copy and paste a formatted citation or use one of the options to export in your chosen format


EXPORT



APA

Asker, A., & Ünal, T. (2020). National State Building, Islamic Policy and Regional Cooperation in Georgia during the Period of Independence. Journal of Eurasian Inquiries, 9(2), 125-139. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.010


AMA

Asker A, Ünal T. National State Building, Islamic Policy and Regional Cooperation in Georgia during the Period of Independence. Journal of Eurasian Inquiries. 2020;9(2):125-139. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.010


ABNT

Asker, A.; Ünal, T. National State Building, Islamic Policy and Regional Cooperation in Georgia during the Period of Independence. Journal of Eurasian Inquiries, [Publisher Location], v. 9, n. 2, p. 125-139, 2020.


Chicago: Author-Date Style

Asker, Ali, and Tuğba Ünal. 2020. “National State Building, Islamic Policy and Regional Cooperation in Georgia during the Period of Independence.” Journal of Eurasian Inquiries 9, no. 2: 125-139. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.010


Chicago: Humanities Style

Asker, Ali, and Tuğba Ünal. National State Building, Islamic Policy and Regional Cooperation in Georgia during the Period of Independence.” Journal of Eurasian Inquiries 9, no. 2 (Apr. 2024): 125-139. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.010


Harvard: Australian Style

Asker, A & Ünal, T 2020, 'National State Building, Islamic Policy and Regional Cooperation in Georgia during the Period of Independence', Journal of Eurasian Inquiries, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 125-139, viewed 27 Apr. 2024, https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.010


Harvard: Author-Date Style

Asker, A. and Ünal, T. (2020) ‘National State Building, Islamic Policy and Regional Cooperation in Georgia during the Period of Independence’, Journal of Eurasian Inquiries, 9(2), pp. 125-139. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.010 (27 Apr. 2024).


MLA

Asker, Ali, and Tuğba Ünal. National State Building, Islamic Policy and Regional Cooperation in Georgia during the Period of Independence.” Journal of Eurasian Inquiries, vol. 9, no. 2, 2020, pp. 125-139. [Database Container], https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.010


Vancouver

Asker A, Ünal T. National State Building, Islamic Policy and Regional Cooperation in Georgia during the Period of Independence. Journal of Eurasian Inquiries [Internet]. 27 Apr. 2024 [cited 27 Apr. 2024];9(2):125-139. Available from: https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.010 doi: 10.26650/jes.2020.010


ISNAD

Asker, Ali - Ünal, Tuğba. National State Building, Islamic Policy and Regional Cooperation in Georgia during the Period of Independence”. Journal of Eurasian Inquiries 9/2 (Apr. 2024): 125-139. https://doi.org/10.26650/jes.2020.010



TIMELINE


Submitted27.03.2020
Accepted13.09.2020
Published Online30.09.2020

LICENCE


Attribution-NonCommercial (CC BY-NC)

This license lets others remix, tweak, and build upon your work non-commercially, and although their new works must also acknowledge you and be non-commercial, they don’t have to license their derivative works on the same terms.


SHARE




Istanbul University Press aims to contribute to the dissemination of ever growing scientific knowledge through publication of high quality scientific journals and books in accordance with the international publishing standards and ethics. Istanbul University Press follows an open access, non-commercial, scholarly publishing.